Comingsoon on Alexander

Film's website: Alexanderthemovie.com

Colin Farrell talks Alexander

The Alamo
Amazing Grace
American Gangster
The Aviator
Becoming Jane
Charlie Wilson's War
Cinderella Man
Cold Mountain
DaVinci Code
Elizabeth: the Golden Age
Finding Neverland
Flags of our Fathers
Glory Road
The Great Raid
King Arthur
Kingdom of Heaven
Last Samurai
Master and Commander
Memoirs of a Geisha
Miracle at St. Anna
Miss Potter
Motorcycle Diaries
National Treasure
National Treasure 2
The New World
Oliver Twist
The Other Boleyn Girl
Passion of the Christ
Pride and Prejudice
Pirates of the Caribbean 2
United 93
Vanity Fair
Walk the Line
We are Marshall
World Trade Center

ALEXANDER (opened 11/ 24/04)

Oliver Stone's Costly History Lesson

Director Oliver Stone spent years of his life and $150 million to recreate on film the life of Alexander the Great (played by Colin Farrell)

A film epic is a costly way to deliver a history lesson. But if done with an eye to accuracy (and of course, deep pockets) there's no other medium like it to evoke the grandest spectacles from the past.

Alexander does a bang-up job of restaging some colossal historical battles, with authentic weaponry, charging camels, rearing elephants, and a cast of thousands. The film also vividly recreates vignettes from long-dead societies, like the boisterous drinking parties of the Macedonian elite, and the exquisite beauty of Babylon's ancient city.

But $150 million can't always buy you a great story, or memorable dialogue. For this film, the moments of historic spectacle have to carry it. Here's what to glean from its history.

Q. Was there some historical reason for the odd accents in this film?
A. It's disconcerting to hear Scottish burrs and Irish brogues in an epic about the ancient Greek world. (Although, interestingly, the Irish-born Colin Farrell spoke with an American accent, and the American-born Angelina Jolie spoke with, well, an accent apparently of her own imagining.)

Oliver Stone has said that the Scottish and Irish lilts were deliberate, meant to evoke the language difference between Greece and its northern neighbor, Macedonia-Alexander's homeland. Macedonians
spoke an accented Greek, scorned by 'proper' Greeks as uncouth.

A creative concept, but unfortunately, it simply sounds silly. Even though we know that everyone in the ancient world didn't speak in plummy British accents, it's become a convention we expect in our toga
movies. Imagine the shock if Russell Crowe used his native Australian accent in Gladiator. G'day, Maximus.

Q. So, was Alexander gay?
A. Ah, the gay question. Stone's film alludes to lots of
relationships-male and female-for Alexander, but focuses primarily on his intense attachment to his lifelong male companion, Hephaistion.

Though bashed by some, Stone's depiction of Alexander's sex life meshes with current historical interpretations. The evidence suggests (though it doesn't prove) that Alexander had intimate relationships with men as well as women throughout his life. And though the film may overplay it at times, his favoritism towards Hephaistion is well

And the context of the times must also be considered. Bisexual behavior was typical for elite Greeks and Macedonians, including Alexander's own father, Philip. Greek philosophers, like Alexander's famed tutor, Aristotle, taught the Greek conventional wisdom: that intense relationships-sexual or otherwise-were most appropriate between men
(being the superior sex, and all). There was little concern in the Greek world for the 'hetero' and 'homo' labels our society adheres to.

Q. Did Alexander's mother really keep that many snakes?
A. Stone goes over the top with this one. Every scene with Olympias (Angelina Jolie) shows a snake either coiled in her lap, twined around her arms, or curled up on her bed. It's more than a little creepy, but
there is some historical basis for it. Olympias was remembered for being a snake-charmer, and also was an enthusiastic follower of the god, Dionysius, whose rituals often involved numerous snakes coiling
themselves around dancers' bodies.

Q. Did Olympias, have a hand in arranging King Philip's death?
A. Alexander had one hell of a dysfunctional family, as the film stresses repeatedly. Historians suspect that Olympias, in her ruthless determination to further her son's interests, arranged for the murder of her husband, who had recently taken another wife (of 'purer' lineage than Olympias) and fathered an infant son. Some historians suggest that Alexander himself was complicit in his father's murder. In the film he isn't, but in reality, we'll never know for sure.

Q. Did the real Alexander wear the mini-skirt battle tunic sported by Farrell?
A. Images from that era show that, yes, indeed, Alexander and his Macedonian and Greek warriors donned those fetching short tunics for battle. In fact, they revered their battle 'skirts' as manly, and
sneered at the 'girly' pants worn in battle by their Persian opponents.

Q. Early in the film we see a huge battle. How accurate is it?
A. The Battle of Gaugamela was key to Alexander's conquest of Persia (centered in today's Iran and Iraq.) Its recreation on film has some spectacular moments, and is heavily based on recorded history, including
Alexander's refusal to launch a surprise night attack despite his army being vastly outnumbered; Macedonia's famous battle phalanx-a tightly
disciplined, massed infantry unit wielding eighteen-foot pikes; Alexander's perfectly timed cavalry attack which won the day; and King Darius of Persia hightailing it off the field while his army went down
in defeat.

Q. What made Alexander 'Great?'
A. The film never offers a coherent explanation to that question, and thus Oliver Stone's Alexander is far less interesting than the historical Alexander. The actual Alexander was fearless, charismatic, a brilliant tactician, a genius at leading men and empires, and an
intensely curious intellectual. He pushed himself and his troops onward not only to conquer the next hill but to see what wonders lay beyond it.

A tyrant to some, a benevolent despot to others, his empire reshaped the world politically and intellectually. By encouraging the diffusion of Greek culture and learning throughout the known world, Alexander's empire profoundly shaped the development of Western civilization.

Not much of this is to be found in Stone's film. Watch it for the spectacle, then come home and curl up with a good biography of this fascinating guy. (I like Alan Fildes and Joann Fletcher's Alexander the Great.)

By Cathy Schultz, Ph.D.

Dayton Daily News, November 24, 2004. (Also in Joliet Herald News, November 28, 2004; Bend Bulletin, November 28, 2004; Providence Journal, November 26, 2004.)

Love the blond 'do

© 2004 History in the Movies